GENERAL RESULTS
 
 
 
  
Uncovering one of the largest Mesolithic Sites in the UK
 
 
 
  COLOUR
  Buchan
  flint
  can
  occur
  in
  a
  variety
  of
  colours:
  
  yellows,
  reds
  and
  browns
  predominate
  at
  Skelmuir
  Hill,
  whereas 
  medium
  -
  pale
  grey
  flint
  is
  dominant
  at
  Boddam
  Den,
  
  although
  this
  distinction
  is
  not
  sufficient
  for
  allocation
  of 
  a source. 
  The
  main
  colours
  on
  the
  Crathes
  site
  are
  brown,
  yellow,
  red,
  orange,
  grey.
  
  However,
  there
  was
  every 
  combination
  in
  between!
  
  James
  said
  to
  use
  the
  Mundol
  charts,
  but
  I
  soon
  gave
  up
  on
  this
  as
  there
  were 
  variations
  in
  colour
  in
  most
  pieces,
  and
  some
  had
  different
  colours
  e.g
  brown
  with
  a
  black
  layer
  under
  the 
  cortex.
  Some very general observations:
  Whitish tended to be coarser grained and often opaque
  Orange/brownish orange tended to be finer grained 
  Paler
  grey
  flints
  tended
  to
  be
  more
  coarse
  grained,
  whereas
  the
  dark
  grey/black
  tended
  to
  be
  finer 
  grained, some very dark/black was very fine grained, yet in thinner areas almost transparent.
  Yellow:
  
  much
  of
  the
  initially
  yellow
  flint
  became
  much
  browner
  over
  time
  whereas
  some,
  of
  a
  richer 
  deeper yellow retained its colour.
  Red, grey and whitish flint retained its colour
  Suspect brown/yellowish brownmay become more orange-y over time?
  In
  the
  end,
  I
  decided
  to
  use
  T
  Ballin’s
  (2014)
  basic
  colour
  classification
  of
  brown-yellow-orange,
  red,
  grey,
  with 
  the
  addtion
  of
  black
  and
  whitish
  for
  this
  report.
  
  Even
  so,
  this
  assessment
  has
  to
  be
  subjective,
  rather
  than 
  objective:
  
  eg:
  deciding
  whether
  a
  flint
  is
  brownish
  grey
  (ie
  Grey)
  or
  greyish
  brown
  (ie
  Brown)
  
  is
  not
  always 
  easy.  Flints designated as ‘whitish’ tended to be more whitish than pale grey.
  As heat/burning can change the colour of the flint, only unburnt pieces were asessed.  
 
 
  THE SCATTER
  Although
  the
  scatter
  (see
  chart)
  is
  continuous
  there
  are
  two
  major
  intensive
  areas,
  each
  with
  possibly
  associated 
  sub-sites:
  Nether Mills West:  NM 1 extending into NM 2,
  Nether Mills East: extending well into NM 4 and NM 3;  includes the JBK dig site
  Milton
  Cottage:
  
  less
  intensive
  and
  could
  well
  extend
  into
  the
  football
  pitch
  area,
  bordered
  by
  the
  Coy
  Burn, 
  at the West.  It may be a sub-site relating to NMW.
  Consequently
  I
  refer
  in
  this
  report
  to
  Nethermills
  East
  (NME),
  Nethermills
  West
  (NMW),
  and
  Milton
  Cottage
  (MC)
  as 
  being simple and logical, rather than the confusing and misleading array of names in Canmore and SMR.
  (Nether
  Mills
  West:
  previously
  Durris
  Bridge
  (Canmore)
  
  and
  Crathes
  Mains
  (Abdnshire
  SMR)
  both
  referring
  to
  the
  same 
  collection.
  Although
  the
  bridge
  is
  officially
  the
  Durris
  Bridge,
  this
  collection
  is
  from
  Crathes,
  not
  Durris,
  is
  at
  the
  north 
  edge of the field not near the bridge, and is from Nether Mills Farm not Crathes Mains.)
  The
  bulk
  of
  the
  Nether
  Mills
  flints
  were
  found
  along
  the
  middle
  river
  terrace
  except
  for
  those
  in
  NM
  1
  on
  an
  ‘island’ 
  of
  higher
  ground
  on
  the
  lower
  terrace.
  
  This
  is
  close
  to
  the
  SW
  edge
  of
  the
  middle
  terrace
  and
  seems
  to
  extend
  into 
  the
  E
  edge
  of
  MC.
  
  The
  material
  from
  MC
  was
  mostly
  on
  the
  higher
  areas
  along
  the
  river
  bank
  (ie
  the
  lower 
  terrace).
  
  In
  general
  the
  river
  braiding
  is
  reflected
  by
  the
  scatter
  concentrations,
  as
  they
  were
  mostly
  on
  the
  higher 
  ground in all five fields (see Google map below).
  James
  Kenworthy’s
  excavation
  was
  situated
  near
  the
  SW
  corner
  of
  NM
  4,
  an
  extremely
  small
  part
  of
  NME
  let
  alone 
  the
  whole
  of
  the
  Crathes
  scatter.
  
  The
  concentration
  at
  the
  major
  site,
  NMW,
  is
  more
  intense
  than
  that
  at
  NME.
  It 
  must
  be
  remembered,
  however,
  that
  approximately
  30,000
  flints
  were
  removed
  from
  NME
  during
  James’ 
  excavation.
 
 
  LITHICS
  The material
  With the exception of two agate pieces and one anomalous piece, the assemblage was of flint.  
  This
  siliceous
  stone
  was
  attractive
  to
  prehistoric
  people
  because
  it
  can
  be
  worked
  in
  a
  predictable
  and 
  repeatable
  way
  to
  produce
  sharp
  edges
  and/or
  to
  manufacture
  implements.
  
  It
  is
  a
  very
  hard
  material,
  and
  as
  it 
  is
  almost
  indestructable,
  the
  presence
  of
  worked
  flint
  may
  be
  the
  only
  remaining
  indication
  of
  prehistoric 
  activity.
  Flint
  pebbles
  do
  not
  occur
  in
  the
  River
  Dee 
  (JBK,
  Interim
  Report)
  and
  James
  referred
  to 
  the
  flint
  found
  at
  Crathes
  as
  Buchan
  flint.
   
  Although
  there
  are
  flint
  mines
  in
  Buchan
  at 
  Skelmuir
  Hill
  and
  Den
  of
  Boddam,
  associated 
  with
  the
  Neolithic,
  it
  is
  thought
  that 
  Mesolithic
  people
  (8000-4000BC)
  made
  use 
  of
  beach
  pebbles
  along
  the
  coast,
  and 
  surface
  pebbles
  in
  Buchan
  
  (D
  R
  Bridgeland
   
  2000)
 
 
 
  Five
  years
  of
  fieldwalking
  revealed
  a
  continuous
  scatter
  of
  flints
  through
  the
  five 
  fields:
  1.75
  km
  along
  the
  river
  bank
  and
  250m
  to
  the
  north
  in
  the
  widest
  part,
  one
  of 
  the largest Mesolithic sites in the UK (Caroline Wickham-Jones  2016, page 50)
 
 
 
  Table GR 1:   Crathes:  Presence/absence of types at each site
 
 
 
  Type
 
 
 
  MC
 
 
 
  NMW
 
 
 
  NME
 
 
 
  Cores
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Meso broad blade microliths (larger)
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Meso broad blade microlliths (smaller)
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  no
 
 
 
  Meso narrow blade microliths
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Meso microburins
 
 
 
  no
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Early Neo leaf-shaped arrowheads
 
 
 
  no
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Neo flaked knives
 
 
 
  no
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Neo ground and polished knife
 
 
 
  no
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  no
 
 
 
  Scrapers
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Blades
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Flakes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Split pebbles
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  Possible Neo potsherd
 
 
 
  no
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  yes
 
 
 
  For more details and definitions of types,  see
   Lithic Analysis
  
 
 
  Table GR 2:   Colour percentages from all unburnt flints at each site
 
 
 
  Attribute \ Site
 
 
 
  MC
 
 
 
  NMW
 
 
 
  NME
 
 
 
  Total flints
 
 
 
  711
 
 
 
  4,543
 
 
 
  4,638
 
 
 
  Unburnt flints
 
 
 
  509
 
 
 
  3,331
 
 
 
  3,747
 
 
 
  % Brown
 
 
 
  41.3
 
 
 
  73.4
 
 
 
  75.3
 
 
 
  % Grey
 
 
 
  39.3
 
 
 
  14.2
 
 
 
  12.6
 
 
 
  % Red
 
 
 
  6.9
 
 
 
  7.4
 
 
 
  8.7
 
 
 
  % Whitish
 
 
 
  10.7
 
 
 
  4.5
 
 
 
  3.1
 
 
 
  % Black
 
 
 
  1.8
 
 
 
  0.5
 
 
 
  0.3
 
 
 
  % Pink
 
 
 
  0.2
 
 
 
  included with red
 
 
 
  included with red
 
 
 
 
  Table GR 3:   Milton Cottage:  Colour percentages from 2008 + 2011
 
 
 
  Attribute \ Year
 
 
 
  2008
 
 
 
  2011
 
 
 
  2008 + 2011
 
 
 
  Total flints
 
 
 
  206
 
 
 
  505
 
 
 
  711
 
 
 
  Unburnt flints
 
 
 
  169
 
 
 
  340
 
 
 
  509
 
 
 
  % Brown
 
 
 
  30.0
 
 
 
  47.1
 
 
 
  41.3
 
 
 
  % Grey
 
 
 
  51.8
 
 
 
  33.3
 
 
 
  39.3
 
 
 
  % Red
 
 
 
  7.1
 
 
 
  6.8
 
 
 
  6.9
 
 
 
  % Whitish
 
 
 
  10.7
 
 
 
  10.6
 
 
 
  10.7
 
 
 
  % Black
 
 
 
  0.6
 
 
 
  2.4
 
 
 
  1.8
 
 
 
  % Pink
 
 
 
  0.6
 
 
 
  0.0
 
 
 
  0.2
 
 
 
 
  Table GR 4:Nethermills West,  NM 2:   Colour percentages from
  2010 and 2011
 
 
 
  Attribute \ Year
 
 
 
  2010
 
 
 
  2011
 
 
 
  2010 + 2011
 
 
 
  Total flints
 
 
 
  294
 
 
 
  478
 
 
 
  772
 
 
 
  Unburnt
 
 
 
  230
 
 
 
  346
 
 
 
  576
 
 
 
  % Brown
 
 
 
  86.9
 
 
 
  76.0
 
 
 
  80.4
 
 
 
  % Grey
 
 
 
  6.1
 
 
 
  9.0
 
 
 
  7.8
 
 
 
  % Red
 
 
 
  4.3
 
 
 
  10.7
 
 
 
  8.2
 
 
 
  % Whitish
 
 
 
  2.6
 
 
 
  3.5
 
 
 
  3.1
 
 
 
  % Black
 
 
 
  0
 
 
 
  0
 
 
 
  0
 
 
 
  % Pink
 
 
 
  0
 
 
 
  0.9
 
 
 
  0.5
 
 
 
 
  MC
 
 
 
  NETHERMILLS WEST
 
 
  NM 1
 
 
  NM 2
 
 
  NM 3
 
 
  NM 4
 
 
  NETHERMILLS EAST
 
 
  MILTON COTTAGE
 
 
 
  Milton Cottage (MC)
  MC
  CR 2011
  Nethermills West (NME)
  NM 1,1A 
  CR 2008
  NM 2
  CR 2011
  Nethermills East (NMW)
  NM 3,4
  CR 2009
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  The scatterplot, showing the find-point grid references of lithics collected during the years 2008, 2009 
  and 2011.  Field NM 1A is at the north of NM 1. 
 
 
 
  Even
  during
  fieldwalking
  it
  was
  apparent
  that
  there
  was
  a
  higher
  proportion
  of
  grey
  flint
  at
  MC
  and
  later 
  analysis
  confirmed
  this
  (Table
  GR
  3).
  
  However,
  although
  the
  percentage
  of
  grey
  flint
  was
  substantially
  higher 
  than
  that
  of
  brown
  flint
  in
  2008,
  in
  2011
  the
  brown
  flint
  percentage
  was
  just
  slightly
  higher
  
  than
  that
  of
  the 
  grey (Table GR 3).  The other colours, as with NMW and NME, were in smaller numbers (Table GR 3).
 
 
 
  The
  overall
  percentages
  of
  brown
  and
  
  grey
  flint
  at
  Nethermills
  West
  and
  Nethermills
  East
  were
  very
  similar, 
  with
  the
  brown
  flint
  comprise
  much
  the
  largest
  group,
  and
  the
  grey
  a
  poor
  second.
  
  Other
  flint
  colours
  were 
  less
  in
  evidence.
  
  Milton
  Cottage,
  however,
  had
  almost
  equal
  proportions
  of
  grey
  flint,
  (but
  see
  Table
  GR
  3 
  below).  The remaining flint colours were in low numbers.
 
 
  Burnt or not
  Pieces
  showing
  crazing,
  cracking
  were
  recorded
  as
  burnt,
  whereas
  those
  with
  red
  tinges
  were
  recorded
  as 
  slightly burnt.  Several ‘pot-lids’ were picked up.
  Burnt flint was found throughout the area, concentrations possibly reflecting the intensities of the scatters.
  Numbers
  may
  be
  an
  underestimate
  as
  it
  is
  possible
  that
  flint
  can
  be
  heated
  with
  no
  noticeable
  change
  in 
  colour. 
  Heating
  can
  make
  the
  flint
  easier
  to
  work,
  but
  I
  am
  not
  aware
  of
  any
  evidence
  of
  this
  procedure
  here
  or 
  elsewhere on Deeside.
  (This section is in preparation.)
 
 
  For an overall site comparison the combined flint totals from each site were used to compile the percentages.  
  Table GR 2 comprises the flints from:
   Milton Cottage: 2008+2011,  
  Nethermills West:  NM 1 2008+2012 + NM 2:  2010+2011,  
  Nethermills East: 2009
 
 
 
  Colour percentages at each site
 
 
  Comparison of percentages in different years
 
 
  In
  2008,
  Milton
  Cottage
  was
  ploughed
  late,
  and
  had
  no
  weathering
  before
  being
  drilled
  a
  few
  days
  later. 
  Some
  pieces
  seemed
  to
  be
  ‘surface
  stained’
  by
  the
  surrounding
  silty/sandy
  substrate
  colour,
  and
  some 
  even
  seemed
  to
  have
  a
  very
  thin
  layer
  of
  substrate
  strongly
  adhering
  to
  the
  surface
  (James
  said
  they 
  looked
  as
  if
  they
  needed
  a
  good
  scrub!).
  
  
  I’ve
  wondered
  since
  if
  these
  flints
  had
  just
  been
  unearthed
  for 
  the first time, and they hadn’t been exposed long enough to be ‘cleaned’ by weathering?
  The
  percentage
  of
  grey
  flints
  was
  lower
  in
  2011.
  
  Maybe
  any
  staining/adhering
  substrate
  on
  brown
  flints 
  resulted
  in
  them
  not
  being
  so
  easily
  discernable
  in
  2008,
  but
  not
  all
  flints
  were
  affected.
  
  Nevertheless,
  this 
  is a large difference between the two years!
 
 
  Milton Cottage
 
 
  (Still to be completed)
 
 
  Reference
  D
  R
  Bridgeland
  
  (2000)
  
  Flint-rich
  gravels
  in
  Aberdeenshire,
  in
  The
  Quaternary
  of
  the
  Banffshire
  Coast
  &
  Buchan,
   
  Field Guide, edited by J W Merrit, E R Connell & D R Bridgeland.  Quaternary Research Association,  page 98.
 
 
  The assemblage
  During
  the
  process
  of
  tool-making,
  many
  waste
  pieces
  are
  produced.
  
  Where
  large
  scale
  flint-knapping
  has
  taken 
  place, the resulting debitage can form the bulk of a collection, and this was certainly the case in Crathes.
  Although
  much
  of
  the
  material
  is
  broken/damaged,
  all
  phases
  of
  manufacture
  are
  present,
  from
  the
  preparation 
  of
  the
  raw
  material
  to
  the
  production
  of
  finished
  tools.
  Cores,
  mostly
  single
  platform,
  and
  a
  variety
  of
  scrapers 
  form
  part
  of
  the
  collection.
  The
  major
  component
  is
  of
  Mesolithic
  technology.
  
  
  Finds
  diagnostic
  of
  the
  Mesolithic 
  include
  microliths
  and
  microburins,
  with
  the
  ‘broad
  blade’
  (possibly
  earlier)
  technology
  represented
  by
  large 
  wide-based
  triangles
  and
  oblique
  points,
  and
  the
  ‘narrow-blade’
  (possibly
  later)
  technology
  by
  crescents
  and 
  backed bladelets. Three smaller wide-based triangles may be from an intermediate stage.  
  The
  other
  component
  of
  this
  site
  is
  Neolithic.
  Our
  most
  spectacular
  find
  was
  a
  very
  fine
  Middle
  to
  Late
  Neolithic 
  ground
  and
  polished
  knife.
  
  
  Other
  Neolithic
  finds
  include
  two
  small
  flaked
  knives,
  four
  Early
  Neolithic
  leaf-
  shaped arrowheads (1 almost whole, 3 broken) and 2 small possible Early Neolithic potsherds (Table GR 1). 
 
 
 
  
 
 
  
 
 
  The black circles represent the grid references at edge of the field.  
  The
  Google
  map
  shows
  NM
  2,
  the
  Field
  Label
  button
  indicates
  the
  positon
  of
  the
  terraces,
  the
  Scatterplot 
  button
  shows
  the
  ditribution
  of
  the
  flints,
  and
  the
  Concentration
  button
  gives
  the
  number
  of
  flints
  in
  each 
  10m x 10m square, and the   Most squares at the edges of the field extend beyond the boundaries.
  The
  scatter
  is
  almost
  totally
  confined
  to
  the
  middle
  terrace,
  with
  a
  few
  at
  the
  base
  of
  the
  bank
  and
  a
  few, 
  mostly at the east edge extending part of the way down the eroding edge of the middle terrace.